Debate, adulation and anger surfaced this week toward Show Low coach Randy Ricedorff (once a Mesa Westwood state champion as a player and a Warriors assistant). This after he left his son, Rathen, into the second half to break the Arizona record for passing touchdowns (9) despite a 52-0 halftime lead against Chinle.
The situation and ensuing debate has leaked out nationally, and I found several comments and thoughts from parties involved intriguing, to say the least (and apparently a few parties which weren’t involved, such as the mayor).
From the Rivals story:
They said: “Every kid that dressed played. That spoke a lot on their behalf. They made every effort to keep the score as low as possible. If they wanted to, they could have went three digits on us.” –Chinle athletic director Steve Troglia
I say: Seems like Troglia either believes that, or is taking the high road and not interested in getting into a pissing contest or war of words about the situation. It’s not about how many points Show Low could have scored (it probably could have been 80 or 90). It’s that, if the team’s starting quarterback is still in the game trying to throw touchdown passes for some boring record in a 52-0 game, then where is “every effort to keep the score as low as possible?”
They said: “I feel that people have the perspective that Show Low is not a class program,” he said. “You don’t like that there are people who were not at the game and go by hearsay. The perception is the problem.” –Ricedorff
I say: He’s right in that perception is (or could be) a problem, but you leave yourself wide open to this when you’re throwing the ball with your starting quarterback midway through the third quarter. Why do we have to be at the game to believe you shouldn’t be throwing the ball to appease your kids who are clamoring for a record when it’s 52-0? Some things are pretty black-and-white.
They said: “We know it’s going to be a blowout. Whether we run the ball or throw the ball is not going to make a difference.” –Ricedorff
I say: Not going to make a difference? See “Perception” above.
They said: “Obviously the game was a runaway, (but) if the other team is not complaining, I would think what our team did was fine.” –Show Low mayor Steve Fernau
I say: What does the mayor have to do with this story? As opposed to, say, other schools who’ve been involved in a similar situation(s)? Beyond that, why does one team have to openly complain for the other team to set its standards on sportsmanship?
An oldage: What’s popular isn’t always right. What’s right isn’t always popular.
For all we know, Randy Ricedorff has been a quality, first-class coach for more than 20 years, and he can’t be blamed for the scheduling because most of that is beyond his control.
But this game offered a host of teaching moments about priorities that he whiffed on in a big way.