Rarely does officiating figure into story or blog content. It’s a thankless job, they’re not professionals and human error occurs.
No one ruling or call ultimately decides an outcome.
But even this one is confounding.
No. 7 Gilbert Highland trailed No. 2 St. Mary’s, 1-0, in the top of the seventh inning during Tuesday’s second round of the 5A Division I state softball championship.
The Hawks had a runner on second (Ashleigh Seipel) with two outs and Caitlin Konicek batting against Knights aceDallas Escobedo.
According to Hawks coach Jamie Waldron:
Konicek swung and missed at the first pitch for strike 1, took two balls, then swung and missed again for strike two.
Konicek stepped out of the box to look at Waldron and take a practice swing.
That’s when Knights coach Bobby Pacheco called time, went to home plate and claimed Konicek swung at strike three which should have ended the game.
Waldron, the scorekeepers and the home plate umpire had two strikes in their counters. There were no game-ending cheers by Knights fans, no players appeared ready to leave the field and Escobedo was ready to throw another pitch.
“(Pacheco) must have been the only one at the field who thought it was a third strike,” Waldron said.
Pacheco then went to the field umpire, who casually strolled into the infield and said it was strike three.
The game ended and the umpires jettisoned to the parking lot.
The Hawks were livid. If it was strike three, how come nobody cheered or celebrated the end of the game? How come the home plate umpire didn’t have final say on what the count was? And if it was strike three, why didn’t either umpire make a declaration or signal the game was over?
Waldron is contemplating filing a protest with the AIA, though she knows it probably won’t change this outcome, and it would have been a tall task for Konicke to drive home Seipel with the tying run against Escobedo.
But the Hawks at least wanted a full chance.
Was Pacheco right and everyone else wrong about the count? Was intimidation involved?
Nobody knows, but in a state tournament, this was a bush-league ending to an otherwise excellent softball game.